Ask the Expert: Your Supplement Questions, Answered
A Life Time registered dietitian joins us to answer some common questions about dietary supplementation to cut through the confusion and help you make more confident, informed choices.



Do you really need a multivitamin? Can a healthy diet replace supplements? And with so many products promising big results, what does a high-quality supplement actually look like? In this episode, Paul Kriegler, RD, joins us to answer some common questions about dietary supplementation.
If navigating the supplement aisle feels overwhelming and flashy marketing and endless options leave you confused about what your body needs, this episode will help cut through the confusion so you can make more confident, informed choices.
Paul Kriegler is a registered dietitian and the senior director of product development for LTH supplements at Life Time.
In this episode, Kriegler answers some common questions about dietary supplements, explaining how to choose, use, and get the most from them.
- “Can I just eat a healthy diet and not worry about supplements — or just take supplements and not worry about my diet?” You likely need both. A nutrient-rich diet and a smart supplement routine work best together. Supplements can’t undo a poor diet, and it’s often impossible to cover every nutrient gap with a healthy diet alone.
- “Who needs to take a multivitamin?” Nearly everyone. Kriegler points to the latest figures from the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (NHANES), which showed that 21 of the 24 nutrients they examined were insufficient or deficient across multiple population groups. A quality multivitamin can provide a reliable nutrient baseline.
- “What’s your opinion on skipping a multivitamin and taking only targeted supplements?” Kriegler compares it to choosing faucets or fixtures for your house before you’ve poured the foundation. Unless you get a blood test that shows you’re deficient in iron — so you know specifically that you need iron, for example — it’s generally advised to cover essential vitamins and minerals with a quality multivitamin.
- “What are the most common nutrient gaps dietary supplements can help fill?” Kriegler shares the top 10 gaps: fiber, vitamin D, magnesium, omega-3s, potassium, choline, calcium, vitamin E, vitamin C, and zinc.
- “What are your thoughts about soil depletion and declining nutrient levels in food?” Depleted soil produces less nutrient-dense food, so produce today may not deliver what it once did. Modern life adds to the problem: Chronic stress, medications, and environmental exposures all draw down your nutrient stores, making it even more important to fill those gaps.
- “What advice do you have for savvy consumers who want a high-quality product?” Treat any “magic bullet” product with healthy skepticism. Be wary of bold claims, products that are unusually cheap, and pricey products that lean heavily on marketing. Look for third-party certifications and talk with a trusted professional with credentials (versus a social media influencer, for example). Always consult with your doctor or healthcare provider before adding a new supplement to your routine.
- “How much of a supplement can your body absorb and use?” Your body absorbs what it needs and clears the rest, so some excretion is normal and not wasted money (if you’re using a high-quality product). Form does matter: Many once-daily tablets are tightly compressed with binders and can pass through without fully breaking down. Loose-powder capsules release nutrients more readily.
- “What does it mean for a supplement to be methylated, and who benefits?” A methylated nutrient comes in an active form your body can use right away. For example, methylfolate absorbs easily, while roughly half the population doesn’t process synthetic folic acid well.
Transcript: Ask the Expert: Your Supplement Questions, Answered
David Freeman
Welcome back to another episode of Life Time Talks. I’m David Freeman.
Jamie Martin
And I’m Jamie Martin.
David Freeman
And today’s topic is common questions about supplements. Navigating the supplement aisle can feel overwhelming, with flashy marketing and endless options leaving many people unsure of what their bodies actually need.
To cut through the confusion, this episode’s guest will be answering some commonly asked questions about dietary supplements so you can make confident, informed choices. Who do we have with us today, Jamie?
Jamie Martin
Yeah, back with us again this season is Paul Kriegler. He’s a registered dietitian and the senior director of product development for LTH supplements at Life Time, and one of our most common guests. Hi, Paul. How are you?
Paul Kriegler
Great. Thanks for inviting me back.
Jamie Martin
Yeah, welcome. We always love these episodes.
David Freeman
All right. Let’s get right into it. You ready? Ready.
Okay, first question: Can I eat a healthy diet and not worry about supplements? Or flip it: Can I just take supplements and not worry about a diet?
Paul Kriegler
You should eat a healthy diet. Mm-hmm. You should also probably supplement with something.
David Freeman
Okay.
Jamie Martin
Tell us more.
Paul Kriegler
So unfortunately, no, you can’t just eat food and think you have every base covered, and we’ll probably get into that. But you also can’t just take supplements and expect that to undo poor choices on the food side. So it’s got to be a holistic approach.
Jamie Martin
Right. It’s a both-and proposition here.
So let’s talk a little bit about the why behind that, and why whole foods alone might not be enough. We’ve had different people in the functional medicine space tell us, in different stories we’ve done, that because of the nutrient quality in our soil, we’re not getting the same nutrients that we were maybe fifty years ago. Is that part of why supplementation might help?
Paul Kriegler
Yep, that’s a meaningful reason why. The soil quality has diminished nutrient supply in the soil, so it goes on up the food chain to us. We’re just getting less nutrition from the food, even if it’s grown this decade versus five decades ago.
So that’s a big factor. The other things are just modern lifestyle. There are many reasons that our bodies deplete or actually lose nutrients through certain modern lifestyle choices. Chronic stress is one of them. Prescription and over-the-counter drugs, all the environmental exposures we have. There are a lot of reasons why our nutrient status today isn’t the same as it was a few generations ago.
David Freeman
Yeah, in a lot of ways, deficient, based off some of the factors y’all just mentioned.
We talk about multivitamins. Does everyone need to be taking a multivitamin? Knowing where we currently are in this space and knowing how nutrient-deficient a lot of individuals are, does everybody need to be taking one?
Paul Kriegler
I think so.
And the data seems to point in that direction too. If you look at the NHANES data, the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey, and there have been several of those, the latest figures I’ve seen say twenty-one of the twenty-four nutrients they look at are either insufficient or deficient in multiple population groups.
So basically, no matter how you split the population, every segment of that population is missing multiple nutrients from what they’re considering the adequate intake level, which is a separate target than how much you need to operate at your full potential.
So right there in the nutrition data, which is a small snapshot and observational data, it seems to shine a light on a big problem with our nutrition adequacy.
Jamie Martin
Got it.
Well, let’s talk about that, because there are a lot of people who say, “I’m going to skip the multivitamin and take these more targeted individual supplements instead.” What’s your take on that? Is that a good approach, or does it depend?
Paul Kriegler
If you like complication, that’s a good approach.
Jamie Martin
All right, tell us more.
Paul Kriegler
I liken it to picking out faucets and fixtures in your house but not caring about the foundation or the framing. You’re trying to put the cart before the horse in a way.
In some instances, it’s super obvious. You get an iron test from your doctor or something like that, and you know you’re deficient in iron. That’s a clear signal to supplement with iron.
But in general, a lot of people should be on a multivitamin just to cover their bases of those essential vitamins and minerals.
Jamie Martin
Yep. I want to talk about multivitamins a little more, specifically the amounts that are in the typical multivitamin.
We’ve had a lot of people ask us questions like, “Why are there so many in Life Time’s multivitamins? There’s an AM version and a PM version. Why so many? And why is it not just one pill? It’s three for each of those.”
Let’s talk about the amount that’s in a typical, or maybe average, multivitamin that’s available.
Paul Kriegler
Yeah, the historical approach is to make the multivitamin either half or one hundred percent of whatever the established daily value is. And that daily value is based on the amount of that nutrient that’s required to keep people who are sedentary from developing obvious clinical deficiency syndromes.
So it’s kind of the baseline, the very minimal baseline. Again, it’s a separate target from someone who’s aiming to operate at their full potential or achieve all the things they want to achieve, and who’s stressing their body out with exercise and high life demands. Those are completely separate scenarios.
So the once-daily approach with multivitamins is good. It covers some bases, but it may not be good enough in some other contexts. A lot of the daily values are potentially very outdated. They’re aimed at a very minimalistic approach.
Whereas active people, like the population we interface with at Life Time, are putting a lot more demands on their bodies. They have activity levels that are far beyond sedentary, so their nutrition needs are completely different. In some instances, they’re much higher. So you’ll see overages, sometimes in the thousand-percent range of the daily value.
That looks alarming, but it’s just because the daily values are for a very specific purpose relative to sedentary populations not developing deficiencies, whereas higher dosages are aimed at helping people achieve optimal function.
Jamie Martin
When you say you might see overages, where might somebody see that? Are you saying if they were to get lab work done, they might see that there?
Paul Kriegler
No, you’re looking at the inflated values in the daily values column, honestly.
Jamie Martin
You’re talking about the actual label.
Paul Kriegler
Yes.
Jamie Martin
I just wanted to get clarity on that.
Paul Kriegler
And most of those excesses are in the water-soluble nutrients, which run a much lower risk of toxicity because your body continually flushes out whatever excess you take in. It’s pretty efficient at absorbing what it needs and then letting the rest go.
David Freeman
So the simplicity piece. I want to go back to it just because you don’t want to be taking all these different pills if you can get it all within one.
And then we were talking about the quantity just now as far as taking an AM and PM, and we were referencing our LTH multivitamin. When it comes to quality, that’s another piece too, as far as regulation. Anybody who’s listening right now is like, “All right, I’m going to go take my X multivitamin,” whatever that may be.
But when it comes to what we do within the LTH umbrella, what makes our multivitamin different from the others?
Paul Kriegler
Yeah. I’ll backpedal a little bit to the AM/PM thing.
There’s one approach where you can just take one multivitamin a day, a tablet a day or whatever. Those typically have lower payloads or lower doses just to cover the minimal baseline needs. The tablet forms are smashed together in a pill. They have some fillers and binders to make everything congeal together, and then they’re heat-pressed or pressure-pressed together. Those often don’t break down. We just excrete them whole or nearly whole.
So that’s not really worth the effort.
Jamie Martin
Or money. Yeah, right.
Paul Kriegler
If you don’t do that approach and you put the loose powder of the nutrients into a capsule, obviously there’s a little bit of space in between each of the particulates, so it just takes up more space. That’s what leads you to higher dosages, because it’s less tightly packed together.
And splitting it into AM/PM is because we have more specific needs for energy production during the day versus recovery and rest at night. So those are multiple formulation choices that Life Time has made for our particular product.
In one way, it’s to make sure you don’t take six of those at once. You take three in the morning and three at night, with food —
Jamie Martin
Spread it out. Yep.
Paul Kriegler
— because your body needs nutrients kind of continuously.
David Freeman
And what about the process as far as ensuring the quality of our products? I know you’ve shared this in the past, but just for first-time listeners, what is that process to make sure there’s quality in what they’re putting in their body?
Paul Kriegler
Sure. We partner with manufacturing companies that are based in the US. They’re all FDA-registered facilities, and they’re additionally audited and certified by an independent third party, NSF.
NSF goes into their facility every year and audits everything, from the physical plant conditions to how they qualify and maintain the raw material suppliers sending them ingredients, how they train their people, and how they operate their machinery. They look at how they keep records, what their quality control points and processes are for product release, and then adverse event reporting.
So it’s a really robust manufacturing audit and supply chain audit, if you will. That’s table stakes. We only do manufacturing that happens in the US, even though we get raw materials from global sources. And then it’s independently audited and certified.
David Freeman
That NSF, can you break down the acronym for our listeners?
Paul Kriegler
Yeah, nowadays they just go by NSF. It used to be the National Sanitation Foundation.
David Freeman
Okay.
Paul Kriegler
It’s an independent third-party organization. They’re worldwide, and their whole mission is to uphold consumer safety.
David Freeman
Okay. Mm-hmm.
Jamie Martin
Awesome. Okay, let’s get into some of the most common nutrient gaps that dietary supplements can fill. What are those?
Paul Kriegler
Oof. Yeah, if somebody goes searching, if they’re nerdy like me, for the top ten nutrients that people fall short on, there’s a long list of them in that NHANES data I mentioned earlier. I brought a list so I wouldn’t forget any, so I’m going to reference it.
The top ten include fiber, vitamin D, magnesium, omega-3s, potassium — and it goes multiple pages, look at this — choline, calcium, vitamin E, vitamin C, ironically, and zinc.
Those are the ones the NHANES data show are most commonly missed relative to their adequate intake level, not even the optimal intake level.
Jamie Martin
Got it.
Paul Kriegler
And I listed them from highest priority on down. With fiber, ninety-plus percent of the population, based on those metrics, is not meeting the AI.
Jamie Martin
Not even getting the basic level that’s needed. Right. Okay.
Paul Kriegler
Yeah.
David Freeman
What is the recommended amount of fiber in a day?
Paul Kriegler
It’s twenty-five to thirty-eight grams. Less for women. Those are the adult figures. Thirty-eight grams is recommended for men.
David Freeman
I got you.
Jamie Martin
I’m kind of going off script here, but we keep hearing about this trend of fiber maxing. Is this part of the reason that’s happening? You’re seeing it all over TikTok, all over Instagram. What’s happening there?
Paul Kriegler
Well, for the last five years or so, there’s been this great proteinification of our food supply. Bodybuilders were onto it decades ago, supplementing with protein to get more optimal intakes. Well, if you just throw protein into a fiber-deficient diet, it causes problems.
Now the industry’s kind of catching up. Fiber in the right forms is very beneficial and often needs to be supplemented. If people are eating typical or average amounts of processed foods in North America, their baseline nutrition choices aren’t going to meet their fiber needs.
Jamie Martin
Right. And we know that we get fiber from a lot of the produce we’re eating, and most people aren’t getting the recommended daily amount of produce or the other whole foods that are good sources of it.
Paul Kriegler
Exactly.
David Freeman
Yeah, I like the deficiencies you threw out there. All right, we’re staying on script on this one. I want to talk about vitamin D, zinc, and magnesium.
Starting with vitamin D: What is happening to the body if you’re deficient in it? Then we can come to zinc and magnesium. Can you explain for our listeners why it’s important to have enough and not be deficient?
Paul Kriegler
Yeah. Vitamin D is critical for bone health. This was figured out, I believe, in the forties. They started adding vitamin D and vitamin A to the milk supply. That was one way to get the population sufficient, or closer to sufficient, in vitamin D to avoid rickets.
Rickets was a disorder of young children. As they grew and got heavier, their body weight would cause their legs to curve or bow if they didn’t have adequate vitamin D. That’s because vitamin D plays critical roles in calcium absorption and bone formation. That’s the primary thing it’s known for.
It’s also critical for other hormone signaling pathways, mood, and immune function. Vitamin D actually acts more like a hormone and signaling molecule than a pure vitamin. But it got grouped in with the vitamins because its functions are so vital. Without it, you can’t be healthy or achieve optimal health.
Jamie Martin
Yeah. When I asked this question, vitamin D was the first one I thought of, before fiber. I figured vitamin D and magnesium would be right at the top. So how many people are deficient in vitamin D?
Paul Kriegler
Sixty-five percent. Some figures say eighty percent of the North American population is insufficient or has low levels of vitamin D.
It’s complicated, because it’s partly low intake of vitamin D from the natural food supply. Again, milk is fortified, and it’s the number one source of vitamin D, but you’d have to drink something like two and a half to three gallons of milk to meet your adequate intake level. So it’s completely impractical.
Or you’ve got to get outside in the sun, because your body makes it from sunlight exposure.
David Freeman
How much time in the sun?
Paul Kriegler
Fifteen minutes midday, with your face, hands, and arms exposed, during the summer or non-winter months here in Minnesota. Longer if you have darker skin tones. Longer if you’re wearing sunscreen, because sunscreen blocks the UV rays that help stimulate vitamin D production.
And then in the winter, you have no chance. You could be outside naked and you’re not going to make any vitamin D in Minnesota.
David Freeman
At the tail end of the vitamin D part, you were talking about immune function. So let’s go into zinc next. Talk to us about what happens if you’re deficient or depleted in zinc.
Paul Kriegler
Yeah, zinc is critical for brain health, recovery, and hormone health. It’s vital for testosterone production. But zinc is also critical for immune function. It helps with how your blood cells and immune cells form in your bone marrow.
It also has some structural capabilities when it comes to interrupting the process of how viruses replicate once they get into your cells. That’s why there’s some evidence showing that even zinc lozenges during cold and flu season can help prevent and reduce the occurrence of illnesses and shorten the timeline of an illness. So if you do get sick, it helps shorten it or lessen the severity.
David Freeman
So we’ve got vitamin D and zinc, and the last one we threw out was magnesium. This is a big one.
Paul Kriegler
Yep. The soil is just depleted of magnesium, and then you add food processing on top of that. Plus there are all the reasons in modern life that we lose magnesium from our bodies, which include drinking coffee and alcohol, sweating regularly, and chronic stress. That stress response causes you to excrete more magnesium.
What’s tricky about that one is it’s extremely rare to take someone off the street, check the magnesium level in their blood — that’s called serum magnesium — and have it show up out of range.
Magnesium is so important that your body does anything and everything it possibly can to maintain that serum level. It might pull magnesium out of your bones to keep that level stable and supply magnesium to the body, because it needs it so critically. So it’s super rare to see it fall out of that range.
That’s what makes it tricky. No one thinks they’re deficient, but almost everyone is insufficient in magnesium.
Jamie Martin
Yeah. And to your point, it’s so important. Isn’t it something like three hundred-plus functions in the body that need magnesium?
Paul Kriegler
And that’s the low number. Now we’re seeing something like six hundred or more processes or steps in our metabolism where magnesium performs critical roles.
Jamie Martin
Wow.
Okay, let’s talk a little bit about regulation, because we know quality isn’t always a given with supplements. What’s the status of supplement regulation in the US right now?
Paul Kriegler
The FDA has a framework for how supplements should be manufactured and what ingredients can and can’t be in supplements. So ultimately, the FDA has regulatory authority over supplements.
They also have regulatory authority and responsibility over drugs, both prescription and over-the-counter, as well as cosmetics and food. It’s a big job — a big collection of jobs.
Supplements have a different regulatory framework than drugs and cosmetics. It’s closer to food.
Jamie Martin
Okay.
Paul Kriegler
So you could say the regulations are looser on the supplement industry. The onus is put on the supplement manufacturers or the brands selling the supplements to adhere to good manufacturing practices. That’s what I mentioned earlier: NSF goes in and checks on these manufacturers to make sure they’re complying with GMPs.
Jamie Martin
So staying on top of them.
Paul Kriegler
Yeah. It’s kind of like speed limit laws. You can speed on the highway a little bit, and nobody knows until you get caught. That’s kind of how the supplement industry has been able to operate.
There’s enough leeway, and enough of a backlog of audits and investigations the FDA has to do in the supplement industry, that someone could feasibly start up a company, start selling products, maybe or maybe not notify the FDA they’re selling those products, make a pretty profit, and then later down the line get popped. Or get shut down by the FDA and maybe have to pay back some of their profits.
So in that regard, it’s often seen as a dirty industry, because there are loopholes that people do take advantage of.
Jamie Martin
Yep. I think you’ve described this in the past as reactive regulation — not until I get caught do I do something. Have there ever been any instances at Life Time where we’ve run into issues?
Paul Kriegler
Yeah. We launched a product over a decade ago, and within the first thousand units sold, there was a bit of a signal of people having stomachaches. I think a couple of individuals went and got checked out at the hospital.
It had an ingredient in it that’s been used in other supplements and by other brands. But in that case, we weren’t comfortable with the number of people who reached out and said, “I didn’t feel good on this.” So we did a voluntary market withdrawal.
Jamie Martin
Okay.
Paul Kriegler
So we self-regulated before the FDA stepped in and said, “You’ve got to do this or you’re in trouble.”
We monitor these instances using a third-party service for adverse event reporting. There’s a phone number on our packages. If anyone ever feels not normal or bad and suspects one of our supplements is part of that, they call the number, and we log all the details.
We open investigations across the board with us and our manufacturing partners. We get down to the root cause and then figure out whether it’s a reportable event to the FDA or whether we can resolve it on our own with the consumers.
Jamie Martin
Right. And to go off of that a little more, we know there are literally thousands upon thousands of supplement products on the market. How common is that kind of effort? It does feel like it’s reactive versus taking a proactive approach and testing. There’s also the “generally recognized as safe” thing, right?
Paul Kriegler
Yes.
Jamie Martin
So what are your thoughts on that?
Paul Kriegler
Yeah. Supplements at their most basic level are nutrients that are lacking or insufficient in the diet. You’re putting them in a more convenient, more consistent form that looks and often feels like a medication or an over-the-counter drug.
The ingredients chosen by companies should have generally recognized as safe status, or they should be actual food nutrients recognized by the FDA.
We’re pretty careful and pretty conservative about that. We’ve got to have some sort of GRAS documentation on all the nutrients that go into the product. And then we have that adverse event reporting, of course.
Even with that, you do have to actively manage quality control. If somebody’s vitamin smells funnier than it used to, we look into it. If the capsule isn’t filled all the way, we’re looking into what happened. And we’re documenting all of it so we have a record.
It’s the same thing on the drug side. People think supplements are inherently dangerous, but they’re not. And there are people doing it the right way, arguably almost to the level drug manufacturers are expected to operate.
But even with tighter regulations on the drug side, if you go to the FDA’s website and look up their recall notices, there have been almost three hundred recalls of metformin, a very common drug with ninety-plus million prescriptions written a year. Three hundred FDA-mandated recall notices —
Jamie Martin
Wow.
Paul Kriegler
— for impurities, cancer-causing impurities, since 2020. So supplements aren’t the bad guy.
All consumer products have safety risks, and all of them need active monitoring. The degree to which some companies in the supplement industry do that is a huge question mark for me. It’s not a question mark for me at Life Time.
David Freeman
Yeah. With the way technology continues to advance, and everything you just said, it’s about making sure there’s quality assurance behind our supplements.
Then there’s social media and influencer marketing. I can search for something for my back because it’s in pain, and all of a sudden I see an advertisement saying, “This can help your back.” In the world we live in now, everything is so readily available. And we want a solution, and we want it fast.
Paul Kriegler
Right. Immediate.
David Freeman
Yeah. Whether it’s acute or chronic, we want to be pain-free, or we want to look a certain way or be able to lift a certain amount.
So with all that, I hear what you’re saying. It’s more about how we help support and educate people before they take that route — these are the steps you should probably take before purchasing.
What advice would you give our listeners when they’re thinking, “All right, I’m about to take this supplement because it looks good and it promised me these things”? What educational tips would you give those individuals?
Paul Kriegler
Always check with your doctor first, especially if you’re taking prescription or over-the-counter medications, managing chronic health conditions, or you’re pregnant or nursing. Your doctor should be in lockstep with you on all major health updates you’re making, supplements included.
Some of the big red flags: Are the claims so bold or too good to be true that it raises your spidey sense a little? I’d be suspicious.
There’s a little price screening you can do, too. If something is cheap, something was cut short along the way to make it so cheap. Or if it’s super expensive and their ads are everywhere and they’re super high-quality ads, you may be buying from a marketing company that happens to sell a product instead of a product company that does marketing.
Those are some of the red flags. Then there’s anything that promises to do more than it actually does. That requires a little more research. But with AI now, it’s crazy. You could say, “Tell me more about this product and what actual human studies support the ingredients and dosages for my situation.”
Sometimes it hallucinates, but it reasonably points you in the right direction, and you can ask more questions, keep digging in, and fine-tune your prompts a little.
The big red flags for me are: Are you getting health advice from somewhere you probably shouldn’t, like social media? Are they credentialed? Are they pure in intent? Are they making promises they’d be able to uphold if challenged, or are they just running the risk and not getting caught by the FDA or FTC for their advertising practices quite yet?
Those are the loopholes that are wide open in this social media age.
Jamie Martin
Wide open. And it’s also about being aware of who’s saying it. It’s not just companies — again, to the point of influencers, we’re hearing from a lot of individuals who may be perceived a certain way. You might think this person is an RD or whatever, but you have to do your own due diligence and understand what this person is sharing and why they’re sharing it.
Paul Kriegler
Yeah. And then there’s what to look for: third-party certification. NSF is one of them. There’s Informed Choice and Informed Sport. Eurofins is a global lab company that has a certification now. There’s Clean Label Project, SUPCO. There are all kinds of independent third-party certification programs you can look for.
But the best approach is to consult with your doctor. If you have a trusted fitness or nutrition professional who’s well-versed in this area, and they’re recommending a third-party-certified brand or product, you’re probably on a better path than self-guided shopping or listening to the Costco sample person or the teenager at the vitamin store.
Jamie Martin
Right. You mentioned earlier that some of a vitamin might get excreted in urine. That can be a criticism of dietary supplements: “Why would I take this if it’s just going to be expensive pee?”
Can you speak to how much of a given supplement the body is able to absorb and use? Are there some that are easier for the body to absorb, and which ones might get excreted more?
Paul Kriegler
Yeah. What you’re describing is a normal regulation process, and it happens with other substances too. The body is pretty smart. When you consume anything, it’ll absorb what it needs and excrete the excess. That’s normal regulation.
If you take cheap forms of vitamins or nutrients, it’s different. I’ll give you a specific example: synthetic folic acid versus methylfolate. Their fates within the body, and how efficiently we can absorb and use them, are meaningfully different, especially for some people.
Synthetic folic acid happens to be in bread and cereal —
Jamie Martin
Yeah.
Paul Kriegler
— as part of the food fortification program. Roughly half the population doesn’t process it properly.
Jamie Martin
Tied to methylation, right?
Paul Kriegler
Yeah. Those people have to convert folic acid into its metabolically active form, methylfolate, in the body after taking it. Anything left over in its folic acid form that isn’t converted can build up and potentially cause issues down the road. There are known problems that unmetabolized folic acid can cause.
Whereas methylfolate, which is a water-soluble vitamin, is super easy to absorb. It’s directly usable by your body because it’s in the form your body needs, and any excess is easily excreted.
We could go down many rabbit holes here. Iron, for example, has a five to thirty-five percent absorption rate depending on how much your body needs. If you need more of it, your absorption rate will be higher than someone who has sufficient levels of iron.
So there’s this cool self-regulation of many nutrients. But you’d never expect your body to use every single milligram of everything you take. That’s just not how it operates. It takes —
Jamie Martin
Takes what it needs.
Paul Kriegler
— what it needs and excretes the excess. Yeah.
David Freeman
In that same vein, let’s talk about the timing of taking certain supplements. We mentioned zinc, vitamin D, magnesium, and multivitamins at certain times of day. I know we covered AM and PM, so those are pretty much set.
But is it better to take vitamin D after a meal, or midmorning, or zinc at a certain time? How would you frame up the timing of taking supplements?
Paul Kriegler
Yeah, there are a lot of nuances there too. In general, fat-soluble vitamins — A, D, E, and K, and I’d even throw fish oil into the mix if you’re taking it — are better absorbed with a meal.
Jamie Martin
Okay. Any meal?
Paul Kriegler
Any typical meal that’s got some fat in it. If it has some fat, I would consider it a meal. Carbs, protein, and fat combine to make a meal. If you just have carbs, it’s a snack. If you just have protein, it’s a snack. Often there’s some fat with protein.
So, fat-soluble vitamins with a meal. Vitamin D is generally better in the morning because it’s kind of a daytime sunshine vitamin. It’s not necessarily going to have a stimulating effect if you take it at night, but it’s generally better in the morning.
B vitamins probably have more utility if taken earlier in the day because they’re very involved in energy production. That’s not to say your body isn’t producing and using energy at night, but it’s using it at a higher rate during the day, during your waking hours.
Jamie Martin
Could they ever keep you awake if you took them at night? You’d probably have to take a lot, if that was the case.
Paul Kriegler
You’d have to take a lot, because they’re not a central nervous system stimulant.
B6 is actually involved in serotonin production. So you could argue that taking B6 at night, which is in our Relax supplement, helps —
David Freeman
One of my favorites.
Paul Kriegler
— keep your serotonin pools where they need to be to then trickle down into the melatonin production pathway.
So it’s not that you should only take B vitamins in the morning. It’s just that’s generally when they’d be more helpful metabolically.
Zinc: I would separate zinc from dairy and calcium intake if you can, because there are some competing absorption pathways. Same thing with iron. Iron and calcium are not friends, so take them separately. Iron with vitamin C — take those together.
David Freeman
What’s that window, would you say?
Paul Kriegler
Probably sixty minutes or so apart, at least. It depends on your gastric emptying time.
Some minerals, including zinc, have their absorption diminished if you consume them with phytates —
David Freeman
Phytates.
Paul Kriegler
— which you find in legumes and beans. There are some studies showing that eating ground beef with black beans significantly reduces zinc absorption from the beef —
David Freeman
Yeah.
Paul Kriegler
— because the beans are interrupting that.
Jamie Martin
I don’t like that, because I like Taco Tuesdays. I have my beef and black beans.
Paul Kriegler
I don’t mean to complicate it. These are just factors you might need to consider. If you really need zinc, we’re going to place it in your plan differently than if you’re just taking a multivitamin to support your daily intake.
Jamie Martin
Right.
David Freeman
And the last one: magnesium. Is that more of an evening supplement, would you say, or does it not matter if you take it in the morning or at night?
Paul Kriegler
People find a lot of help with it in the evening because magnesium is a relaxing mineral. Its counterpart, calcium, helps our nervous system and muscles contract. Magnesium is needed for the relaxation component of muscle function.
So some people, especially those who are magnesium insufficient, generally start taking magnesium at night. But it doesn’t have a sedative effect, so you can take it in the morning, too.
David Freeman
I don’t know if anybody at the table has experienced this, but I think it goes back to the fat-soluble piece: taking a multivitamin on an empty stomach and the nauseous feeling you might get. Why is it important to take it with something in your stomach, and what’s happening when you get that nauseous feeling?
Paul Kriegler
Yeah, there’s anecdotal — and I think some — evidence to support this. If you take zinc on an empty stomach, just a standalone zinc supplement, some people get sneezy.
Jamie Martin
Wow.
Paul Kriegler
A lot of people get an upset stomach and feel nauseous. High-dose B vitamins will do the same thing. They can make you a little nauseous if you don’t have some food to buffer them.
David Freeman
Okay. Thank you, sir.
Jamie Martin
What about the form? For instance, I take a B12 vitamin that I hold under my tongue to absorb. Does that matter? Why might that be recommended, letting it dissolve in your mouth versus swallowing a pill?
Paul Kriegler
For B12 specifically, some people have insufficient levels of what’s called intrinsic factor. It’s a specific protein that’s activated by stomach acid, and it allows you to absorb vitamin B12 from oral intake.
But you can also get B12 through intramuscular injections or sublingual melties.
Jamie Martin
That was the word: sublingual, people.
Paul Kriegler
Yeah. B12 is water-soluble, so you can absorb some of it through your mucosa. People who have low intrinsic factor or low stomach acid might need to take those alternate routes, sublingual or intramuscular.
And think about how many people are on proton pump inhibitors or antacid drugs. It’s hundreds of millions of people. There are known risks with chronic use of antacids or proton pump inhibitors, specifically around mineral status — zinc —
Jamie Martin
Okay.
Paul Kriegler
— magnesium, calcium, and other trace minerals as well. So for some reason you got put on a sublingual.
Jamie Martin
I don’t remember why. Actually, I do know why. I did some genetic testing not too long ago, and something came back related to B12. I don’t remember the specifics right now. It’s been a while, but it was tied to that.
Paul Kriegler
Yeah. It also applies to people who have had gastric bypass, which is way less common nowadays, or a gastric sleeve, or now people on GLP-1s. If that’s affecting gastric function, then alternate intake routes for some vitamins or minerals might be necessary.
Jamie Martin
Okay, since you brought it up, I do want to ask. We’re seeing a rise in GLP-1 use. What about people who are on GLP-1s? Again, this is broad strokes, the bell curve, as our friend Sam often says.
We know that the food noise often goes down, and there’s less of a desire to eat. What role does supplementation potentially play?
Paul Kriegler
A huge role. It matters functionally and metabolically, for getting them on the right path for when they stop the GLP-1. It also matters for symptoms, because some people have side effects from taking those. So they should actively work with their doctor, whoever’s prescribing that program, to figure out which supplements they should be taking.
Here’s what comes to mind for me, understanding the pharmacokinetics and what changes in the body when someone’s on that. A lot of people are going to need fiber for regularity. But fiber makes you feel full. A lot of people need protein. Again, that makes you feel more full. So you’re going to run into issues with total nutrient intake decreasing, which builds a case for a multivitamin.
Beyond that, I think it’s highly personalized. You’re going to have to have an active conversation about supplements and probably make frequent adjustments with your prescribing practitioner.
That goes for anyone on any health journey. If you’re trying to upgrade your health and you’re working with your doctor on a chronic condition, you should see your doctor more often, because you’re going to need more adjustments to your medications or treatment path as you get healthier.
Jamie Martin
Right. And to that end, let’s talk about going in to see the doctor. We talk a lot at Life Time about lab testing, whether it’s an advanced panel to understand nutrient status or whatever you can see through a blood test.
If somebody is working to improve their health, how frequently do you recommend testing to understand where they’re at?
Paul Kriegler
Everybody should get a really robust baseline of where they’re at every year. So annually, I’d say, starting at age 25.
I’m lucky. Well, I’ve got a long history of chronic conditions in my family, so I’ve been gathering data on myself since my early 20s. I like to think that’s an advantage. We’ll see.
A robust baseline includes subjective questionnaires, objective body composition and circumference measurements, and fitness measures like benchmark workouts. It’s anything that gives you a snapshot in time, all the way through to detailed blood work. I think that’s critical.
Then if you find something that’s off and needs your care and attention, retest probably every 60 to 90 days while you’re making adjustments and getting on that better path. That confirms you’re on the right path and in the right rhythm.
Jamie Martin
Yeah. I know several people on GLP-1s, and I’m hearing it’s usually every three months at minimum that they’re getting rechecked to see where things are. If things are changing faster than that, it’s even more frequent, and they stay in constant contact with a healthcare provider.
Paul Kriegler
You get your tires rotated and your oil changed in your car, right?
Jamie Martin
Yeah, absolutely.
Paul Kriegler
So why not do the same for your body?
David Freeman
All right, Paul, we’ve hit on a lot of things. For our listeners and viewers, is there anything we didn’t touch on that you want to make sure they leave with?
Paul Kriegler
I don’t know. What’s your favorite LTH product?
David Freeman
Mine? You heard it. For nighttime, it’s Relax. During the day, I like our Hydrate. And I recently tasted Glacier Rally for the first time. That’s up there too.
Paul Kriegler
Are you still a Blood Orange Hydrate guy?
David Freeman
I actually switched. I like Lemon Lime. Strawberry Lemonade is good too.
Paul Kriegler
The Gatorade flavor.
Jamie Martin
It’s still the go-to.
Paul Kriegler
To me, it tastes like the one you used to get in the glass jar. Classic.
David Freeman
Glass bottles. Yeah, with the condensation on the outside, like the Michael Jordan commercial.
Jamie Martin
Oh, you just gave it away. You gave it away.
My favorite product? I don’t even know. I love Hydrate. That’s a regular part of my routine. But Build is my go-to in the mornings. If I’m having a protein shake, that goes right in, so I get 30 grams of protein right off the bat. I had that yesterday and today. I’d say three to four days a week, that’s my breakfast.
Paul Kriegler
My favorite saying is “30 grams of protein in 30 seconds with no blender.”
Jamie Martin
Yeah. I typically make it more like a shake. But if I can get out the door with that done, it’s a win, because mornings are chaotic. I also feel like I have a whole supplement regimen.
David Freeman
What’s your go-to?
Paul Kriegler
I love my Dream cocktail at night.
David Freeman
Dream is good. I put Relax and Dream together.
Paul Kriegler
Yeah, Mixed Berry Dream. I put the Revive Colostrum in it. It’s just a good ritual at night. It calms me down and gets me ready for bed.
David Freeman
Dream is legit.
Jamie Martin
Over the last couple of days we’ve been recording, I’ve talked a little about my sleep not being the best. I probably need to add Dream, or at least try it and see how it goes.
I love that you add the colostrum too. I visited the plant where colostrum was being manufactured, and the health benefits of some of these unexpected supplements are really interesting. Paul pointed me in that direction a couple of years ago.
All right. I don’t think we missed anything.
Paul Kriegler
Thanks.
Jamie Martin
If there are more specifics we need to get into, we’ll have you back on.
David Freeman
Mic drop moment time. We were talking all about supplements, but from a peptide perspective, is there anything in that space that excites you? Anything you’re looking at and thinking, “This is opening the door to innovation and can help so many people”?
Paul Kriegler
It’s all interesting.
David Freeman
Okay. Is that a teaser for the next episode?
Paul Kriegler
It’s all interesting. The question is how interesting, for whom, and why.
David Freeman
Yeah. I got you.
Paul Kriegler
Obviously, it’s new regulatory territory. We know there are already challenges in FDA supplement regulation, because their bandwidth isn’t what it needs to be.
So I’m cautiously optimistic that something valuable will come from all that energy and research. It’s just a matter of whether we want to be on the leading edge or the bleeding edge of that movement.
David Freeman
I like how you framed that.
Jamie Martin
Interesting. We’re going to be talking a lot about this in our MIORA Performance and Longevity series of podcasts, because we know there’s a lot going on. Jim LaValle, our chief science officer, is in that space all the time. So we’ll be learning more about it there as well.
Paul Kriegler
Yeah, it’s definitely not my wheelhouse. I’m just tangentially staying aware of it.
Jamie Martin
Well, it’s important. It’s what people are putting into their bodies, and that has implications across the board.
Paul Kriegler
I will say this: I don’t think that method of application, like the little pen injectors or at-home injections, is going to apply to much of what we just talked about with nutrients. The dosages just aren’t compatible with that way of taking something.
David Freeman
That makes sense.
Jamie Martin
Okay. All right. Well, Paul, you know we’re going to have more questions another time. It’s just a matter of time before you come back.
Paul Kriegler
You know where to find me.
Jamie Martin
Yes. Where can people find you? You have tons of articles at ExperienceLife.com and many podcast episodes. Anywhere else?
Paul Kriegler
That’s a good start.
Jamie Martin
Sounds good. Thank you, Paul. We always love having you.
More like this
We’d Love to Hear From You
Have thoughts you’d like to share or topic ideas for future episodes? Email us at lttalks@lt.life.
The information in this podcast is intended to provide broad understanding and knowledge of healthcare topics. This information is for educational purposes only and should not be considered complete and should not be used in place of advice from your physician or healthcare provider. We recommend you consult your physician or healthcare professional before beginning or altering your personal exercise, diet or supplementation program.
Life Time provides administrative, non-clinical support to MIORA as well as services and amenities related to general wellness and fitness; Life Time does not provide medical advice, diagnosis, treatment or care.
Advertisement





